Iraq Study Group – Work In Progress

While reading this report (I’m not done yet), it struck me that the Iraq people do not have a national identity nor a loyalty to their country.  Saddam and the dictators through the years have taken care of that.  The Iraq people have loyalties to their tribe, their religious sect, and their country (in that order).

The Iraqi politicians have their work cut out for them.  Resolving centuries-old feuds with religious sect differences is an almost insurmountable task.  Adding to the problem is that each of these different groups is not willing to compromise with any of the others.  Then there are the Saddam loyalists that are lurking in the background…

The Iraq police and military do need to step up and take control of their country.  How soon is the question.  It does beg the question of how much training do they need – I am presuming that some of them had training & credentials under Saddam’s regime, although the question of loyalty does pop up.  And there is no question that these policemen and soldiers have taken far more casualties than the US military as a result of terrorist activities.

The bottom line is that none of this is going to happen overnight.  While the US can kick butt militarily, it’s after that battle is won that the real war, the political one, must be fought and won as well.  My question is:  Will the politicians, both Iraqi and US, have the wherewithal to get the job done?

Advertisements

About Tom Roland

EE for 25 Years, Two Patents - now a certified PMP. Married twice, burned once. One son with Asperger's Syndrome. Two cats. Conservative leaning to the Right. NRA Life Member.
This entry was posted in Iraq, Politics, Terrorism. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Iraq Study Group – Work In Progress

  1. Tom says:

    Tom,
    Agree in general with your assessment: Iraq Study Group aside, there appear to be no easy answers.

    One wonders at even intensive training of Iraqi military/police, given their history of tribal loyalty, internecine religious relationships and recent history.
    In some ways, it was an artificality, like Yugoslavia, disparate peoples held together under a strongman. As much as we would like to see democracy thrive there, the current US philosophy of ‘instant gratification’ runs counter to the time that would take. Perhaps the best we can hope for is that these
    people can achieve peace enough to get on with their daily lives.
    BB-Idaho | 12.12.06 – 9:15 pm | #

    FINALLY AFTER TWO YEARS YOU COME TO THIS CONCLUSION! Maybe republicans are not 100% brain dead.
    Tim | Homepage | 12.13.06 – 11:27 pm | #

    Iraq is a mess. I am not sure it will ever be a place anyone would want to live.
    Teresa | Homepage | 12.14.06 – 12:43 pm | #

    BB – Thank you for your observations. I too have thought of the mess in Bosnia & Yugoslavia, and that bears so many resemblances to the situation in Iraq.

    Tim – Be nice! The dems aren’t any better.

    Teresa – Unfortuantely, there are many who do live there, and the future of that country is uncertain.
    Tom | Homepage | 12.14.06 – 6:40 pm | #

Comments are closed.